A Halloween to Remember

There was a half second of silence. "Oh, my god," Claire gasped. "I'm getting wet just thinking about it."

Suddenly my face paled. I had just stupidly and unwittingly put Cheryl in a terrible position. If she lost, she would have to slide in between Melanie's thighs and lick her pussy. I was pretty sure that Cheryl had never done that before. On the other hand, if she won she would have to put herself on display for all the world to see. I didn't think she was ready for that either. Shit! I had fucked up royally.

Cheryl looked at me like she was going to kill me. "You know," I managed to get out, "Maybe that's not such a great idea after all. How about we just do what Melissa suggested, that the loser does the winner's laundry?" I was ready to die. She must have seen the anguish and remorse written across my face. The others, seemingly ignorant of the glance that had just passed between us, ignored my remark.

Melanie looked at Cheryl, her eyes wide: "I'm game if you are..."

Cheryl stood up, her face a blank mask against the dark sky. "Okay. Let's do it."

The girls walked excitedly back to the place where Claire had dropped the branch. Cheryl picked up her bow and took my arm. "What the fuck do you think you're doing?" she whispered agitatedly. "Do you realize what you just did?"

"Oh god, I am so sorry!" I exclaimed anxiously. "It's just that with all this sex in the air, the party, the punch, I didn't think! I know—I fucked up! You don't have to go through with it—just call it off. I'll give Melanie head if you want. I'll do anything to make it right!"

I was really worked up. Cheryl noticed. "Mark," she said, "You're not going to give Melanie head. Do you have any idea how that would make me feel? Fortunately these girls are my friends, especially Melanie. I don't think I've met anyone besides you since I moved here I feel so comfortable with. But yeah, this is going to be a bitch. The bottom line though, is that I agreed to do it: I made a choice and I'll have to accept the consequences. If I need to learn how to eat pussy I'll do it with a goddamn smile. I'm more worried about what's going to happen if I win."